UPDATE: Former Miss St. Lucia gets off the hook for assaulting, threatening policeman

UPDATE: Former Miss St. Lucia gets off the hook for assaulting, threatening policeman

Patrika Evence is a lucky young woman.

The 1999 National Carnival Queen and her lawyer Wilkie Larcher were today successful in getting an amendment to her conviction for assaulting and threatening to kill a policeman almost one year ago.

However, Magistrate Charon Gardner made the decision under one condition: Evence must submit a letter of apology to the policeman by or before the end of normal business hours tomorrow.

Gardner said she will accept an emailed apology, considering that Evence is currently studying in Taiwan. According to Gardner’s instructions, the letter will be submitted to Evence’s lawyer who will then pass it onto a prosecutor who will in turn submit the document to the officer who was assaulted by the former queen.

The magistrate said she mainly considered Larcher’s application because Evence is at risk of losing her scholarship and the cost associated with such a loss.

Magistrate Gardner further stated that Evence would have learned a lesson based on the damage already done to her reputation with the circulation of the news and the fact that her scholarship was plunged into jeopardy due to the conviction.

The magistrate said she also took into consideration that Evence had no prior convictions, had no known reports against her as a teacher.


Earlier today, Evence’s lawyer, Larcher, submitted an application for the modification to his client’s sentence, saying her reputation and scholarship is jeopardy.

Evence was not present in court on Thursday, Nov. 15 during the sentencing hearing and was therefore slapped with a six-month custodial sentence for hitting an officer in the face with a piece of wood and a 1,000 fine for threatening to kill the same officer.

Evence’s lawyer, Wilkie Larcher, not only asked Magistrate Gardner for a modification to the sentence, but that she considers setting it aside. He noted that she had no prior criminal record.

Larcher said Evence is currently on studying in Taiwan and she may lose this scholarship due to her conviction.

The lawyer also blamed himself for not showing up in court. He told the magistrate that he was aware of the sentencing date, but on that particular day, about the same time the Evence matter was being dealt with, he was attending to a matter in the High Court.

He however noted that a letter was submitted to the magistrate indicating his unavailability.

Larcher pointed out that the law has a provision which allows a magistrate to modify convictions.

In response, Magistrate Gardner had said though she agrees with him that this provision exits, she is still not obligated to give dismiss the conviction or amend it.

Gardner also noted that Evence, as a former national queen and a teacher, should not have behaved in such a matter because she is seen as a role model in St. Lucia.

The trial

Last week Thursday, Evence’s trial proceeded with the prosecution calling the two officers involved in the matter, Acting Coporal 542 Winters and SPC 109 Ezra Deterville, and investigating officer, Constable Richards.

Officer Deterville was the first to take the witness stand.

According to Deterville, on December 11, 2011, at about 10 pm at Caribbean Cocktails bar in Castries, the bar’s proprietor, known as JJ, instructed his staff not to serve Evence, who had attempted to order a drink.

Evence reportedly became agitated, and according to witness testimony, had an exchange of words with the proprietor, threw a drink in his face, and attempted to get behind the bar.

The court was told that two off-duty officers were on the scene and witnessed the entire incident.

Officer Winters prevented Evence from getting behind the bar and she turned around in anger.  Officer Deterville testified that it was at that time he intervened.

Deterville stated: “I noticed that the lady walked toward me in a very aggressive manner.  I stopped her and asked her to calm down.  I tried to get her away from the scene.  She took a piece of wood and knocked me on the left side of my face.”

Deterville said he then released her and heard her say: “You are a dead man”.

Deterville said he felt threatened and made a move towards Evence to place her under arrest, but was advised to refrain by the superior officer on the scene, Winters.

At this point, according to testimony by Winters, they were called away to a disturbance on Jeremie Street, nearby.

At about 11 pm, both witnesses claimed to have returned to the vicinity of Jn Baptiste Street where they had parked their vehicles, and once again encountered Evence.

Both officers claimed to have heard Evence say the following: “I ordered the hit already. You’re a dead man.”

Winters indicated that Evence was pointing to and addressing Deterville while she made the statement.

At that point the two officers arrested Evence and enlisted the assistance of a nearby G4S security vehicle to transport her to the Criminal Investigation Division (CID) where they made a formal report.

From there, the investigating officer, Constable Richards, stated that he interviewed Deterville and the witness.  He then informed Evence of the claims made against her and interviewed her.  To this, it is said that she replied, “I did not mean what I said.”

Richards further stated that he informed Evence that he had suitable grounds to believe that she had committed the offense of assault to the person of Ezra Deterville.

Prosecutor Dominic Leonty asked Richards in court to explain what he meant by suitable grounds. Richards replied that he had observed Deterville to be suffering with pain, and had observed visible swelling on the left side of his face.

Evence has not shown up in court on several occasions and was tried in her absence.

To this end, Magistrate Charon Gardner found Evence guilty of one count of threatening word and one count of assault.

Evence is ordered to pay $1,000 or face four months in prison.  On the count of assault, Evence was issued a custodial sentence of six months.

In sentencing the defendant, Gardner stated that she believes the evidence of the witnesses’ was credible and precise.

A commitment warrant will be issued for Evence in the case of the $1,000 fine and a custodial warrant will also be issued in her name.

Please like our Facebook page, www.facebook.com/stlucianewsonline for instant updates when stories are published here.


No posts to display


  1. ADMIN: Thanks Solange. We have only one staff member who is a trainee so it is quite difficult to juggle the traffic all at once, right now, so appreciate all the help we could get. Keep them coming. Hope you spot those in the Star and Voice too. Sometimes it is worst over there and they have a large staff compared to us.


  2. the justice system in St.Lucia sucks. If the tables were turned. The Police Officer would be on administration leave pending investigation and if found guilty loose his job. Miss Everence just got a slap on the hand and said don't do it again.


  3. I want to know why this reporter is so interested in this particular case? Of all the things happening in the country which bears more significance to the citizenry why is this so important to this reporter that updates are made so frequently?
    I want to know what is happening with all the monies collected from the inception of VAT and where it is being allocated to etc? I want to know about the things affecting me in the country not about who gets punished in court for what and why?


    • ADMIN: The reporter in question is a COURT REPORTER, meaning she covers court on a daily basis therefore if this matter came back up in court, OBVIOUSLY, it would be covered. It is also good journalism to follow-up on cases. A lot of times the other media houses here report on the inception of an incident then leave the public to wonder what the outcome is. Thank you.


      • I commend sno for giving the update on this matter, I think it is very professional to provide updates on cases thank you for great jounalism and whoever is behind this site please continue the great work ....


  4. We have to much freedom in Saint Lucia and as such some of us, who have no control or just choose to engage in non constructive activities abuse those rights.
    I hope they are aware that there is such a thing as deframation of character and you could pay for the words coming out of your mouth if you have no proof of wat you say.


  5. Hmmmmm I tell you. The legal system in St. Lucia sucks big time. She should know better than this. Her unruly behaviour was uncalled for. She should get some form of punishment for acting the fool especially with such a title in St. Lucia. Ms. Evans I would not want you to teach my children. Would you treat them with the same rage?


    • Before u open ur mouth and comment on something you have no information on other than wat people are free to print, you should ask questions. We have to much freedom in lucia we abuse it


      • She was guilty as charged. Get over it. That's why she gets the chance to issue an apology for her behavior and actions.


  6. the 1999 National Carnival Queen should have known better this kind of behaviour is not accepted and a teacher what example is she setting now and her sentence because her scholarship is in jeopardy.What about the rasta man with weed just trying to feed his children? Justice yuh?


Comments are closed.