St. Lucia’s spiral to happy Vat reduction (commentary)

By Melanius Alphonse
Melanius Alphonse

Melanius Alphonse

COMMENTARY – Last week, Prime Minister Allen Chastanet referenced The Fiscal and Structural Reforms in Saint Lucia: Towards a comprehensive agenda prepared by the Caribbean Development Bank (CDB) as “very telling” and “gives a more detailed picture of what is taking place in the economy”.

“The report measured the collection of taxes as a percentage of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) for Saint Lucia and compared it to the rest of the Caribbean. Saint Lucia was in the range of 26 percent, while the entire Caribbean is around 21-22 percent, which in effect means that the island is collecting more money as a percentage of the GDP than any other Caribbean nation. We have been effective at collecting taxes or we are collecting way too many taxes, whichever way you want to be able to put it…we are overtaxed. But that is not the only problem … the fact that investment in the public sector in Saint Lucia is ranked the lowest in terms of the rate of return.

“It means the things that we were investing in, was generating a substantially lesser rate of return than other countries in the Caribbean. So here we are collecting the most taxes but at the same time, they were investing it poorly and as a result, we’ve had low growth, we have had increasing levels of debt, and basically the country is in a mess. The worst part is that the previous administration did not invest in the areas that needed the most support like: the judiciary, security, infrastructure, schools and health care.”

At a basic level the prime minister formulated views meant to reflect his best understanding of the CDB report and what precisely is his own formulation to deliver the expected reduction [and ultimate removal] of the dreaded value added tax (VAT) in a recession economy.

However, the prime minister’s political promise of a reduction of VAT, combined with CDB revenue reform to “reduce the list of VAT exempt and zero-rated goods”, points to double jeopardy.

CDB points to consider in relation to fiscal multipliers read:
“Notably, the study found that only government investment expenditure had a positive and significant fiscal multiplier (0.62). Multipliers associated with changes in tax revenue and government consumption were not found to be statistically different from zero.”

Over the years, the country’s tax systems haven’t raised enough money to pay for overall expenditure, contrary to the prime minister’s arbitrary conclusion that the people are “overtaxed”; nonetheless irresponsible for not taking into account new debt, government handicaps and ongoing increase in recurrent expenditures.

In Trinidad and Tobago, subsequent to 2.5 percent reduction in VAT and several zero-rated items removed from the food basket and becoming taxable meant that consumers paid more for food and beverage and other life essentials on a daily basis. And recently, petroleum dealers have taken the decision to accept only cash at gas stations to cut operating costs and survive. Central Bank money supply could lead to more adverse strain on the economy. Additionally, defying money laundering activities gives impetus to a disquieting crime environment and rule of law index global ranking of 48.

To some extent, Saint Lucia’s political rule is seemingly modeling Trinidad and Tobago. Could similar circumstances play-out in Saint Lucia [rule of law index global ranking 36] or is the marketplace better able to withstand headwinds now dominated by mega-monopolies?

CDB note stimulating consumption vs investment reads:
“The Saint Lucian economy is driven primarily by consumption, which accounts for approximately 82% of GDP, and with private final consumption accounting for 69% of national disposable income, it is likely that if there is a GDP response from adjustments to tax policy, it will come through the consumption channel from the income effect of the reduction. In a small, open economy where a significant portion of the goods consumed will be imported with attendant adverse implications for net international reserves, stimulating GDP growth through consumption is not sustainable.”

Forward guidance of objectives and policy substance are set by politicians; in terms of what could lie ahead to achieve growth through a combination of capital formation, local and foreign investments, increased export capacity, local production and consumption.

However visible, government seems lost with policy fixes, a symptom of a “Five to Stay Alive” fuzzy waffle to deliver an economic plan and clear strategy.

CDB conclusion 2.08 reads:
“Under the baseline scenario, the objectives that GOSL has set for itself will not be realised as fiscal balances and debt are set to become even more unsustainable. Taken on their own, the proposed measures to reduce taxation will exacerbate already unsustainable debt dynamics and, in so doing, impede GOSL’s ability to provide the enabling environment for growth and support to vulnerable groups.

“The implementation of mitigating measures will be necessary so that the functions of government are not compromised. Importantly, these measures can be viewed as an opportunity for GOSL to close revenue leakages and reduce inefficiencies which, under normal circumstances, should have been addressed to ensure fiscal and debt sustainability.”

CDB concluding remarks 5.02 reads:
“As a critical first step towards accelerating and sustaining economic growth, it is necessary that GOSL get its fiscal house in order. Currently, debt dynamics are on an unsustainable path due to the confluence of an inadequate primary surplus, slow growth, and high interest rates. Over time, this could result in critical spending being compromised, such as those for capital investments and social protection. In the current circumstances, implementation of the proposed tax measures in the absence of mitigating measures will exacerbate an already unsustainable situation. The decision to reduce VAT and other tax reducing measures provides an opportunity for GOSL to tackle other revenue and expenditure inefficiencies that have been weighing on finances. It also provides an opportunity to address much-needed structural reforms which could propel growth. Measures to improve productivity are central, but must take place in a facilitative environment inclusive of sound governance structures and supportive institutions.”

And, conclusion 1.24 states:
“Notwithstanding the improvement in recent fiscal performance, public finances are still on an unsustainable path. An initial assessment of the fiscal situation shows that there is tremendous scope for improvement. On the revenue side, generous exemptions, incentives, deductions and allowances are undermining efficiency, and leading to reduced collections. Challenges on the expenditure side highlight the need for greater strategic planning to ensure that resources are targeted to their most productive uses, and is evident in both recurrent and capital spending. With respect to the debt situation, GOSL has managed to keep down interest rates thus far, however, risks abound with the high concentration of short-term debt. Given that the debt strategy speaks to the need to lengthen the maturity structure, and given the low cost of concessional resources, some consideration should also be given to multilateral support.”

Inevitably, government will need to:
• Meet the challenges of innovation and provide direction for a sustainable economy that is equitable in prioritizing and growing sectors of the economy to create fiscal space;
• Merge its priorities with reality and proceed to strengthen public finance to meet the environment in which it seeks to operate and leverage its strengths;
• Innovation is paramount to improve efficiency, closing the gap on trade deficit and borrowing hypocrisy.

Melanius Alphonse is a management and development consultant, a long-standing senior correspondent and a contributing columnist to Caribbean News Now. His areas of focus include political, economic and global security developments, and on the latest news and opinion. His philanthropic interests include advocating for community development, social justice, economic freedom and equality. He contributes to special programming on Radio Free Iyanola, RFI 102.1FM and NewsNow Global affairs and economic analysis. He can be reached at: [email protected]

This article was posted in its entirety as received by This media house does not correct any spelling or grammatical error within press releases and commentaries. The views expressed therein are not necessarily those of, its sponsors or advertisers.


  1. You could definitely see your enthusiasm within the article you write.
    The world hopes for even more passionate writers such as you who are not afraid to say how they believe.

    At all times go after your heart.

  2. Definitely believe that which you said. Your favorite reason seemed to be on the net the
    easiest thing to be aware of. I say to you, I certainly get annoyed while people consider worries that they plainly don't know about.

    You managed to hit the nail upon the top and also defined out
    the whole thing without having side effect , people can take a signal.
    Will probably be back to get more. Thanks

  3. Today, I went to the beach front with my children. I found a sea shell and
    gave it to my 4 year old daughter and said "You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear." She placed the shell to her ear
    and screamed. There was a hermit crab inside and it pinched her ear.
    She never wants to go back! LoL I know this is
    completely off topic but I had to tell someone!

  4. You actually make it appear so easy along with your presentation however I in finding this matter to be
    actually one thing which I think I would never understand.
    It seems too complex and very vast for me. I'm
    looking ahead on your subsequent publish, I'll try to
    get the cling of it!

  5. Great goods from you, man. I've keep in mind your stuff previous to and you are simply extremely fantastic.
    I actually like what you have got here, really like what you are stating and
    the way through which you say it. You make it enjoyable and you still care for to
    keep it sensible. I can not wait to learn much more from
    you. This is actually a great site.

  6. Wow! At last I got a weblog from where I know how to truly obtain useful information regarding my study and knowledge.

  7. I am not positive where you are getting your information, but good topic.
    I needs to spend a while studying much more or working out more.
    Thanks for fantastic information I was in search of this information for my

  8. Who TF is this guy again? It would be nice if SNL provide an excerpt on who this guy is and what qualifies him to say anything he's said.

  9. ignorance there aint enough staff to man most government institutions dont speak on stuff u do not understand

  10. Too many public servants. St. Lucia is like LIAT. 600 employees for 9 aircraft. Just visit the big office of the ministry of foreign affairs in the Baywalk Mall. A lot of employees hardly doing anything.

  11. he must have been asleep when the slp was in power. only the slp thinks they should lower taxes and no one else. every time sno gives this clown his own forum only strengthens my decision to vote for the uwp.

  12. Why doesnt alphonse share his commentary to his pets....we have too many people prepared to talk statistics and have no plan to formulate a better country...yall need to start providing solutions and less critisicism..cause i didnt see the old ways working...


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.