Mary Francis: Don’t blame human rights advocacy, gov’t’s duty to protect citizens from murder

 Share This On:

Mary Francis

Statement by Mary M. Francis, Coordinator, National Centre For Legal Aid and Human Rights Inc.

December 10th is observed world wide as Human Rights Day, for it was on that day in 1948, that the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (U.D.H.R) was promulgated by the General Assembly of the United Nations, as a beacon of hope for a world emerging from the atrocities of the 2nd world war.

As a seminal document the U.D.H.R ushered in a period of Universal Human Rights such as the world had never known. As a milestone document it was declared “as a common standard of achievement for all peoples and all nations.” For the first time in history everyone, everywhere was entitled to enjoy basic human rights.

The U.D.H.R is on the threshold of its 70th Anniversary, in 2018. Human Rights have become a universal language. In fact one writer describes Human Rights as “the world’s first universal modern ideology.” This is rightly so because respect for human rights knows no boundaries, therefore everyone, everywhere in the world is entitled to equality and dignity as human beings, as stated in Articles 1 and 2 of the U.D.H.R.

Article 1: “All human beings are born free in dignity and rights.”

Article 2: “Everyone is entitled to all the rights and freedoms set forth in this Declaration without distinction of any kind, such as race, colour, sex, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth or other status.”

In 1966 two historical Covenants which underpin the U.D.H.R were adopted by the United Nations namely The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and The International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. These two covenants together with the U.D.H.R have come to be known as the International Bill of Human Rights.

Since the promulgation of U.D.H.R the world has seen a plethora of Human Rights Conventions, Covenants and Declarations, the practical effect of which is the existence today, of a strong body of International Human Rights Law applied by national Courts around the world. In addition for the first time in history individual citizens whose country has ratified the 1966 International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, have been given the opportunity of achieving redress for violation of their Human Rights by the State by allowing them to petition the United Nations Human Rights Council to seek redress, and thereby resulting in the State having to comply with the Human Rights standards which are reflected in the International Covenant and its optional protocol.

Regional Human Rights Conventions and Charters have all sprung from the U.D.H.R. For example, the 1954 European Convention on Human Rights, the 1969 American Convention on Human Rights, and closer home Caricom’s Charter of Civil Society 1997.

What of St. Lucia? In practical terms Saint Lucia shares in this body of International Human Rights Law, and the norms and standards underpinning this law. Commencing where it must, with the Supreme Law of the land, which is the St. Lucia Constitution, therein the articles of the U.D.H.R have been incorporated into Chapter I of the Constitution which spells out the Fundamental Rights and Freedoms guaranteed to Everyone in St. Lucia without exception (even the criminal).

Other United Nations Conventions which have been drafted to give effect to the implementation of the 1948 U.D.H.R, and the two International Covenants of 1966, and which have been adopted and later ratified deal with specific groups of people, seen as vulnerable to discrimination or oppression and therefore requiring special protection by the state. Two examples are the 1989 Convention on the Rights of the Child signed and acceded to by St. Lucia in 1991 and the important 1979 Convention on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) which St. Lucia acceded to in 1981.

Today legislation such as the Domestic Violence Act of 1994 and the Family Court are products of St. Lucia’s signing on to CEDAW. There has been a lot of advocacy and activism in the area of Women’s Human Rights in St. Lucia, yet there is still so much violence against women. Consequently much more needs to be done in the forum of continuing education on Women’s Rights as well as including men in this education campaign.

As we observe December 10th Human Rights Day let us reflect on the theme chosen by the United Nations “Stand Up 4 Human Rights.” Indeed everyone in St. Lucia must stand up for Human Rights, because there are many problems such as child abuse, domestic violence, rapes, murder and acts of Police brutality including the still unsolved 2011 murder of 12 citizens (the IMPACS issue and the Shakadan hanging at the Micoud Police Station, whose family members still await justice). Also lack of adequate access to justice for vulnerable persons thereby affording them the Right to a Fair Trial and to Equal Protection of the Law as guaranteed in the Constitution, remains a burning issue for Human Rights Advocates.

There is alarm in the society over the murder rate, for indeed murder and violent crime do raise human rights issues and of course the victims require justice, however rather than blame human rights advocacy for the cause, we must as a people understand that it is the duty of the Government (the State) to protect its citizens from murder and other violent crimes. Investing more in crime fighting and crime prevention is part of the solution in reversing the trend. In the final analysis we all have a part to play. The Police must be adequately trained but we must all practice respect for the rights of others because we share a common humanity.

St. Lucia as a member State of the United Nations has inherited the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (U.D.H.R) which is now customary law. The International Instruments flowing from this Declaration must be taken into consideration by Public Servants, especially the Police. One such International Instrument which ought to inform Police action in the arrest and investigation of Crime, is the 1979 United Nations Code of Conduct for Law Enforcement Officials.

This International Instrument constitute the Police themselves as defenders of Human Rights, and so, despite the menace which crime poses and the great threat to our security, we as a nation must ensure that criminals are not brutalized as it is wrong to treat one act of inhumanity (namely one individual committing a crime against another individual) with another inhumane act, committed by the Police.

In conclusion the U.D.H.R has enabled people the world over to enjoy 69 years of Universal Human Rights. As we embark on its 70th Anniversary, December 10th 2018, the gains of those years must be protected by all nations and all peoples. We in St. Lucia as part of the family of democratic nations, must through education, embrace a culture of Human Rights which is the foundation of peace and democracy. We must all make the Human Rights values of respect, fairness, dignity, equality and tolerance part of our lives, let these values inform our actions towards one another. Above all let Government be our model. In the words of the Preamble of the Declaration (U.D.H.R):

“Every individual and every organ of society shall strive by teaching and education to promote respect for these rights and freedoms.”

On the eve of the 70th Anniversary of the U.D.H.R, as we look ahead, the world community faces new challenges which threaten to erode the gains made. Individual demands are being made for rights which are not fundamental and which were not perceived in the Declaration (U.D.H.R) of 1948. Those demands seem to usher in a “new generation” of rights.

Facing this challenge requires fortitude so as to enable a balance to be struck between maintaining the moral integrity of the society and the demand for new individual rights. One example of which is the right to same sex marriage, the clarion call of the L.G.T.B community, legalized in the U.S.A and other developed Countries. Another area of “new generation rights” is that of environmental rights. Here to it is important also that a balance be struck between a people’s right to development and environmental rights protection.

On this 10th December 2017, in observance of Human Rights Day and inkeeping with the Theme “#STAND UP 4 HUMAN RIGHTS” a call is made to all St. Lucians especially young persons to become champions of Human Rights by joining Human Rights Organizations, so that as citizens, we can work in partnership with Government to ensure to all St. Lucians their fullest enjoyment of Human Rights, civil, political, social, economic and cultural which are interdependent and indivisible.

In the sphere of promotion and observance of Human Rights and in recognition of the 70th Anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948 – 2018), Government is urged to consider the establishment of National Human Rights Commission mentioned in the Report of the Commission on Constitutional Reform. This is a necessary step considering the dysfunctional Justice System currently existing which impacts negatively on the dispensation of justice. In addition such a Commission will ensure the reform of those Laws in St. Lucia, which currently conflict with International Human Rights Conventions ratified by St. Lucia.

Let us all put this year’s theme into action “#STAND UP 4 HUMAN RIGHTS” and take time on December 10th to reflect on the Human Rights values of Peace, Justice, Freedom and Equality.

– Mary M. Francis
Director & Coordinator
National Centre For Legal Aid And Human Rights Inc., established in 1998 in recognition of the 40th Anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights

This article was posted in its entirety as received by This media house does not correct any spelling or grammatical error within press releases and commentaries. The views expressed therein are not necessarily those of, its sponsors or advertisers.


  1. Mary Francis, the person we love to hate – public enemy number one - why? When the rule of law is undermined by law upholders and goes unchecked, human rights are violated and society is veering towards lawlessness. It takes integrity and courage to jump in the driving seat, and steer the machinery of law to be accountable. Mary Francis, in voicing the violation of the law gives voice to the voiceless. In a civilise society the perpetrators also has human rights and the law is also there to protect their human rights. Two wrongs do not make a right. It creates two victims and a broken law machine with far reaching consequences for society.

    Instead of vilifying Mary Francis, recognise that trust and confidence in the law machinery cannot be put right without the acknowledgement that wrongs were committed and victims need to be compensated. Mary Francis did not detract attention from the victims and give it to the perpetrators it was the police that did that by failing to act within the rule of law.

    As a custodian, she is safeguarding human rights for all.

  2. If people are that ignorant then it is obvious that we will need more people like Mary Francis. Ignorance is bound to get you in a problem with government and your rights.

  3. A few people can lift a mirror to a society so that it can see what it truly reflects to itself and to the rest of the world. Mary Francis is one of the sacred few, and by God, it takes integrity and courage to do that! When the rule of law is being undermined by law upholders, she plays her part in making their failings evident. Mary acts as the nation’s ears, eyes and conscience. The day that Mary Francis falls silent and no one else steps in her shoes, will be the day that our society takes a backward step into anarchy and mayhem!

    I praise the Lord for her voice, and the voice she gives to the voiceless. St Lucian is blessed with strong upstanding individuals like Mary Francis. St Lucia still has a long way to go before it can fully embrace human rights and equality for all. If Mary Francis’s wise words are heeded it will truly reflect is the fabric of our society where tolerance, respect, equality and justice are given to all.

  4. like human right don't like abuse.

  5. Mary Francis, you really need to access the current rate of crime and who are the ones committing those crimes. You seek to protect the perpetrators while the victims and families endure the pain.

    • "Mary Francis, you really need to access the current rate of crime and who are the ones committing those crimes." That's the government job. Its not Mary's job to found out who is committing crime. What do you have CID for? Jut to protect incompetent officials you would look to repeat ridiculous and nonsensical demands. Enough already!!

  6. Advocacy ought to protect the rights of the victims. When you seek to protect the rights the perpetrator and overlook that of the victim it creates controversy. It is for this reason you and your organisation are so controversial and maligned.

    • NO. Advocacy cannot protect rights it is the job of law enforcement. How could an NGO protect rights. See how stupid you sound!! This NGO advocates for rights which government denies.

  7. Yaaaawn! Stretch! Yaaaawn! (again).

  8. Another day. Another Ostrich. Or, is it same Ostrich?

  9. Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.