COMMENTARY: Economic contractions only under Labour

The Womb of Helen

The United Workers Party (UWP) is duty bound to enlighten the people of Saint Lucia on the facts about the country’s fiscal problems. The Dr. Kenny Anthony Administration seems to have succeeded in hoodwinking the people of this country into believing that somehow the present crisis is the doing of the UWP.

The Deputy Prime Minister hit the all-time low when he told the nation that the country is in its current state because of the purchase of the Daher Building.

The Daher Building along with 10 acres of residential land at Union was sold to the government for $35M, and $41M to renovate. This would have been funded by a financial institution with no debt to the government as the building was being used as its own collateral. This building has 138 sq feet of floor space and a car park that holds 120 vehicles. The investment would have been paid off by savings and leasing within 12 years; the same period of time that the investment in the new SSDF home is expected to be repaid. So if the Daher transaction caused the country to go into recession in 2012 and 2013 then one must conclude that the purchase of the Coubaril home to house SSDF will cause further recession in the coming years.

The UWP takes full responsibility for allowing the SLP government to mislead the country into believing that the Daher transaction was a disaster without explaining the basics of the purchase to the population. The UWP places the SLP on notice that its PR timidity is a thing of the distant past.

Fellow Saint Lucians, the country’s current fiscal disaster has nothing to do with the UWP Administration. The current economic crisis has everything to do with the bad management of the economy by the SLP Administration which is now inundating you with excuses upon excuses, and blaming everybody else but themselves. The inconvenient truth is that 83 percent of the time that this country has suffered economic contractions – that is negative real GDP growth since Independence – has been when Labour is in power. Now, don’t take our word for it. Visit the IMF website or the Social and Economic Review publications from 1979 to present.

This is no coincidence fellow Saint Lucians. The SLP policies and programmes don’t usually cause economic growth. Their policies are about borrowing lots of money to fund cosmetic activities that will cause you to believe that things are nice, like plastering the country with flags for Independence; and not to mention, paying handouts to SLP supporters at every opportunity.

Coming out of a global financial crisis, one expected there to be fiscal challenges. Every country has had those challenges. But it would take appropriate fiscal policies to address those challenges, not excuses. The UWP suffered challenges in 2009-2011, but did not complain bitterly nor did it look for excuses; instead the UWP implemented policies that grew the economy while managing our debt position with prudence. That is why Saint Lucia recorded growth, albeit small in 2010, and 2011. The UWP handed over a buoyant economy to the SLP. Those are the facts.

The IMF in one of its recent reports, stated that the UWP administration “weathered the storm of the global financial crisis well.” If Saint Vincent, Antigua and Haiti are growing so too would Saint Lucia if we did not have a constitutional lawyer with no Economic or Financial Management skills as our Minister of Finance. But we must give the Deputy Prime Minister credit for being forthcoming with the truth – a rarity you may say. While commenting on the current economic disaster, he confessed by saying that “the decisions we took previously are coming home to bite us.” We are pleased to expand on his statement further by highlighting some of the decisions that brought us here:

1. Upon assuming office in 2011, the Prime Minister sent a tsunami of fear into the domestic economy claiming that the country is in a ‘mess’ and so households need to exercise belt tightening measures and make sacrifices. With growth in 2010-2011 was the country in a mess? Governments usually have to over borrow to spend in post-depression years in order to spur domestic spending, and here we had a prime minister, immediately upon assuming office, putting fear into the minds of households about a messed up country. The UWP never instilled such fear on its households, not even in the midst of the crisis!

2. With aggregate demand falling, VAT should have been held back until aggregate demand rose again. VAT in such a situation will cause recurrent revenue to fall which would naturally exacerbate your fiscal deficit. You see, before VAT, government got its indirect taxes at the ports of entry; but under VAT it is collected at the point of sale and if households are not spending; Government will not collect its revenues.

3. This Labour Government continues to embark upon huge levels of borrowing in programmes that do not grow the economy. In its first year in office since the 2011 elections, the SLP borrowed in one year more than what the last UWP administration borrowed in five years. What is crippling the economy is the fact that those monies are not spent on programmes that stimulate productivity and grow the economy.

So the Deputy PM was spot on; the decisions taken by this Labour Administration are coming back to bite us. If Saint Lucians really knew the record of the SLP in office, I don’t think that they would be eager to reelect them into office. But again, the UWP can only blame itself for being timid with its PR in the past. The SLP has proven to be terrible managers of the economy while excellent in doing things that make you think that they are better managers. In essence, they are better at deception by far.

The UWP party will keep the truth and facts alive. So the next time that you will be asked to choose between the SLP and the UWP, keep the following in mind:

When the SLP took office in 1997, debt to GDP was about 37 percent which the Labour Administration increased by 30 percent, bringing it up to 67 percent by the time they demitted office. The UWP only added a mere three percent to it, between 2006 – 2011, at a time when USA, Japan, Singapore, UK were all borrowing over 100 percent of GDP to resuscitate their economies after the global crisis. In 2011 the Labour Government inherited a debt to GDP ratio of 70 percent. In less than three years they have brought our debt level up to 89 percent of GDP. These are the facts that they refuse to tell you.

(0)(0)
This article was posted in its entirety as received by stlucianewsonline.com. This media house does not correct any spelling or grammatical error within press releases and commentaries. The views expressed therein are not necessarily those of stlucianewsonline.com, its sponsors or advertisers.

22 comments

  1. Fed up with politicians. A bunch of goats leading sheep. its time our people wise up... These guys are using our hard earned money for campaigning on newspapers,and God knows what else. I am Fed Up.

    (0)(0)
  2. Advertisement
  3. If it was so why Uwp did not renovate the building.They were the one who purchase it,why it was not renovated??Stop politicking,all of us are not fools.Not even their supporters will believe that crap.Do you know what structurally unsound means????

    (0)(0)
  4. Advertisement
  5. looshan to the bone

    A whole lot of garbage. ... Until then, please stay out of our faces. Thank you

    (0)(0)
  6. Advertisement
  7. Hipocracy at its best. I have noticed and i don't know if the ordinary citizen has noticed. I don't like comparing political parties but anytime the SLP is criticized constructively then people who support them claim that all politicians are the same. Although not doing any justice to their cause they simply boil it down as to whether you like Kenny D or otherwise.

    Now it is also true that when a Labour Party operative gets conered he will simply say that you are a "Flambeau." I have seldom had to defend the fact that i am nuetral to any other operative because i deal with facts and issues. I understand that a party has to defend itself and guard itself against negative PR but to argue without using any sustainable basis is ridiculus!!!
    I think that the SLP by far has the most well oiled propaganda machinery in all the entities. For how could a party argue that when it does something contraversial in the public eyes its best defence is to point to the past where a previous party did or appear to have done something of the same elk. That is in essence the SLP's real arguement is that if something bad was done to you then we can do it too or we will do this bad thing better. Take VAT "the EVIL & REPRESSIVE tax" for example. Who said those words? Who implemented it?

    (0)(0)
    • finally someone i concur with. Jesus Christ. Stop making politicians treat us like sheep. dont eat everything you are fed. Otherwise your stomachs will be full of shit and you regurgitate the same shit..

      (0)(0)
  8. Advertisement
  9. its clear that these guys are clueless lol all indicators point to that fact. instead of strategies to grow the economy they trying to convince us what a great thing nice and step is. where the investment in agri or the rural sector? Before the elections the present minister of agri would never miss a chance to criticise and beat his chest as someone who could do better, but right now he seem to be MIA. the only people who would say that uwp killed the economy are those who are not living on island or just too political to be honest.

    (0)(0)
  10. Advertisement
  11. SLP has to go however the new UWP is scary. It seems like a bunch of power hungry individuals that cannot be trusted. With Chastnet in charge no better days ahead

    (0)(0)
  12. Advertisement
  13. I am not really into commentaries on such websites, because it is just someone's opinion.

    However, what is said here that we as people are not aware of (even if,) i think he/she is off on one or two points.

    Now only a Fool would believe that any party or Flambeau could invoke a (Fairy like spirit,) to bring wealth, prosperity and stability on this island. And the reason is, we do not control or export anything much to pull us out.
    Our only exporting industry is Tourism, which some of us are bent in destroying.

    Our dismal economic situation will remain like this, until the Factors that be, are able to fully recover, because we are the bottom feeders of the crumbs that fall off their table.

    (0)(0)
  14. Advertisement
  15. At this stage I don't know if I am voting for Red,Yellow or Green!

    (0)(0)
  16. Advertisement
  17. Where are the hacks? where are the better days people? Almost 20hrs and this is the first comment. Stinging facts. KDA screwing the country.

    (0)(0)
    • So, what happen, only supporters of the other side are hacks? Aren't you one? Yes, you are!

      (0)(0)
    • looshan to the bone

      Which facts? Let your former ministers and their cabal know that the people of Saint Lucia wants them to return ALL the monies ... from our coffers and please do it NOW. You all flambeaus are to shameless.

      (0)(0)
      • just like we still waiting for our leader and his crew to refund what was lost through the helenites and rochemel and what we continue to lose due to Grynberg and the shady deals. so if you serious about stopping politicians from stealing we have to take a holistic approach not just focus of one party when more has been lost by the dude you love

        (0)(0)
  18. Advertisement
  19. here we go again,this is known as the blame game,its a culmination of various policies an also the world wide economic downturn,both parties are responsible for the economic woes of st lucia.

    (0)(0)
    • Aren't you aware that the peak of the recession was in 2008-2009? Aren't you aware that the global economy has improve? Aren't you aware that the dept to GDP increased by only 3% during the UWP five reign. That is during the peak of the recession. 3 billion dollars was collect from tourism under SLP compared to 7 billion dollars by UWP during the same length of time.

      (0)(0)
  20. Advertisement
  21. St. Lucia the harsh reality is that we are dealing with two evils and the SLP us the lesser of the 2. We cannot make a mistake and put Allen Chastanet and Co in there. I for one will not be voting because I do not believe that kenny and Co is the right choice. However, allen chastanet cannot be trusted.

    (0)(0)
    • There are the hard facts and you are saying that you will not vote against it in other words "I will not vote them out but they can stay." Where are your comparable facts about Chastanet and the UWP who brought up dept by GDP to only 3% during the peak of the recession (2008-2009). Now,when the global economy has improved our GDP escalated by 19% in 2.5 years and we are not feeling it.

      (0)(0)
  22. Advertisement
  23. great commentary;food for thought.i like it

    (0)(0)
  24. Advertisement
  25. Keep the PR going Flambeau. It is time to send Labour flying to the pit they have dug for the people of this country. They will fall in it.

    (0)(0)
  26. Advertisement
  27. Word up Kenny will not fool me again

    (0)(0)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.